A denied long-term disability (LTD) claim does not mean you have lost your right to benefits. When an insurance company refuses to pay, you can often challenge the decision by reviewing the policy, identifying the reason for the denial, and submitting the evidence needed to support your claim. At J. Price McNamara, we help New Orleans professionals, executives, physicians, nurses, and other high-wage earners pursue wrongfully denied disability benefits.
Before representing claimants, Price McNamara spent years defending insurance companies. As a result, he has firsthand insight into how insurers evaluate medical evidence and make claim decisions.
We understand that LTD disputes often involve complex issues such as medical documentation, policy definitions, benefit limitations, and ERISA appeal requirements. Our New Orleans long-term disability lawyers can help you build a stronger claim record instead of simply arguing with the insurer’s decision.
Schedule a free case evaluation today and learn how a former insurance company attorney can help you understand your options after an LTD denial or delay.
Why Should You Hire Our New Orleans Long-Term Disability Lawyers?
When your long-term disability benefits are denied or delayed, you need a firm that understands both the personal impact of losing income and the legal challenges of pursuing insurance benefits. J. Price McNamara helps clients throughout Louisiana and represents policyholders in disability insurance disputes across the United States.
Because many LTD claims involve ERISA and federal court procedures, we are prepared to handle cases that require a detailed understanding of federal benefit laws.
We understand that a denied disability claim affects more than finances. It can create uncertainty when you are unable to work and need benefits to support yourself and your family. We approach these cases with a focus on clear communication, personal attention, and helping clients understand their available options.
Price McNamara has dedicated decades to disability, life, and AD&D insurance disputes. Our approach is built around understanding how insurers evaluate claims, what evidence matters, and how to challenge decisions that prevent policyholders from receiving benefits.
Importantly, we focus mainly on ERISA-regulated disability, life, and AD&D insurance claims. This narrow focus allows us to address the specific issues that arise in disability disputes, including claim denials, appeals, medical evidence, and insurer reviews.
In addition, Price McNamara’s dedication to disability insurance claims is also shaped by personal experience. Having experienced the loss of family members to disabling illnesses, he understands why disability benefits represent more than a monthly payment. For many families, these benefits provide financial stability during one of the most difficult periods of their lives.
Reach out to us today to learn how we can evaluate your denial or delay and help you understand your legal options under the law.
For a free legal consultation, call (225) 201-8311
Why Do Insurers Deny or Terminate LTD Claims?
Insurance companies deny or terminate long-term disability claims when they believe a policy requirement has not been met or when they find a reason to limit benefit payments. However, an insurer’s decision is not always the final word. Many LTD disputes involve disagreements over medical evidence, policy definitions, or how the insurance company interpreted information in the claim file.
Insurance companies use several common arguments when challenging LTD benefits. These include:
Disputing Doctors’ Statements
In most cases, insurers challenge the opinions of your treating physicians by relying on reviews from their own medical consultants. The insurance company may argue that your doctor’s restrictions are unsupported or inconsistent with the medical records. A New Orleans long-term disability lawyer can review the medical evidence, treatment history, and reasoning behind each opinion to help determine whether the denial was justified.
Saying You Can Perform Sedentary or Light-Duty Work
Another common tactic is claiming that you can return to work in a sedentary or light-duty occupation even if you cannot perform your own job. Insurers may rely on vocational assessments or job descriptions to argue that disability benefits are no longer available. These arguments require careful review of your policy’s definition of disability, your actual job duties, and your medical limitations.
Alleging Insufficient Medical Evidence
Insurance companies may deny claims by stating that the medical records do not provide enough proof of disability. They may focus on missing documentation, gaps in treatment, or records they believe do not clearly explain your restrictions. A strong response requires identifying what evidence the insurer says is missing and addressing those concerns with relevant medical records, physician opinions, functional assessments, or other supporting information.
Issues With a Claim Application
Insurers may investigate whether information provided during the application process was accurate. They may argue that incorrect or incomplete information affects eligibility for benefits. These disputes can depend on what information was provided, whether it was material to the policy decision, and how the insurer handled the application review.
Citing Your Policy’s Exclusions
Another common tactic is relying on policy exclusions or limitations to deny or reduce benefits. Insurers may argue that a medical condition falls outside coverage or that a specific policy restriction applies. The outcome often depends on the exact wording of the policy and whether the insurer correctly applied the exclusion to the facts of your claim.
Requiring Objective Evidence for Subjective Symptoms
Insurers may challenge claims involving symptoms that cannot always be measured through traditional testing, such as chronic pain, fatigue, cognitive difficulties, or certain neurological conditions. They may argue that the available evidence does not objectively prove the severity of the condition. These claims require a complete review of medical records, physician documentation, functional limitations, and how the condition diminishes your ability to perform your job duties.
Our legal team understands how insurers evaluate LTD claims. Reach out to us today to examine your denial or termination and determine the appropriate action to take.
What’s the Difference Between “Own Occupation” and “Any Occupation”?
The difference between “own occupation” and “any occupation” lies in how your LTD policy defines disability and determines whether you qualify for benefits. Many policies first evaluate whether you can perform your specific job and later assess whether you can perform any other reasonable occupation based on your education, training, and experience.
Own occupation coverage focuses on your ability to perform your current job. Under an own occupation definition, you may qualify for benefits if you can’t perform the main duties of your regular occupation. This standard can be especially important for professionals such as physicians, surgeons, executives, and other high-wage earners whose jobs require specific skills or physical demands.
On the other hand, any occupation coverage applies a stricter standard. After a policy’s own occupation period ends, many LTD plans shift to an “any occupation” standard. At that stage, the insurer may evaluate whether you can perform another occupation for which you are reasonably suited based on factors such as your education, training, experience, and functional limitations.
In some cases, a person may no longer be able to perform their previous profession but still face a dispute over whether another type of work is available under the policy’s terms. Insurance companies may rely on vocational reviews or transferable skills analyses when making this determination.
A New Orleans long-term disability lawyer can explain how these definitions apply to your claim because they affect the evidence needed to support your benefits. Call for a free long-term disability claim review and learn how the policy language may impact your claim.
Click to contact our insurance claim lawyers today
Does ERISA or Louisiana Law Govern Your Appeal?
The law that governs your long-term disability appeal depends on how you obtained your coverage. If your disability insurance came through your employer as part of a benefits package, ERISA may control the claim process. ERISA creates specific procedures for challenging benefit denials, including administrative appeal requirements and rules that can affect what evidence is available later if litigation becomes necessary.
Specifically, the appeal stage is often the most important opportunity to build the claim record. Medical evidence, physician opinions, vocational information, and other supporting documentation may need to be submitted before a case reaches federal court.
In contrast, if you purchased your disability policy independently rather than through an employer plan, Louisiana law and the insurance contract may determine how a dispute is handled. These claims may involve issues such as policy interpretation, exclusions, claim handling, and whether the insurer followed the obligations outlined in the agreement.
For ERISA-governed LTD claims, lawsuits are generally filed in federal court. The District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana, New Orleans Division, may be relevant for certain ERISA disputes handled through this office.
Determining whether ERISA or Louisiana law applies is an important first step because the rules, deadlines, and available strategies can differ significantly. Our law firm can review your LTD claim to determine which legal framework applies and what steps may be available after a denial or termination. Contact our New Orleans LTD team to help you understand your options.
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now
What Should You Do After a Long-Term Disability Claim Denial?
The first step after an LTD denial is to understand exactly why the insurance company rejected your claim and gather the records needed to challenge that decision. Request the claim file, Summary Plan Description (SPD), and other plan documents that reveal what information the insurer relied on for denying your claim.
Specifically, do not treat an appeal as a simple disagreement with the insurance company. ERISA disability claims often come down to the difference between an argument and evidence. Insurers expect many claimants to explain why the denial feels unfair, but a successful appeal requires documentation that directly addresses the reasons for the denial.
At J. Price McNamara, we focus on building a stronger claim record through:
- Collecting the policy documents, claim file, medical records, and other relevant information.
- Arranging the evidence to clearly show how your condition affects your ability to work.
- Analyzing weaknesses in the insurer’s reasoning and the issues that need to be addressed.
- Building supporting evidence, including medical opinions and other documentation.
- Submitting a comprehensive appeal designed to protect your claim.
This process matters because ERISA cases are generally reviewed based on the administrative record created during the claim process.
When you complete the required administrative appeal, and the insurer still denies your LTD benefits, you may have the option to pursue a lawsuit in federal court. At that stage, the strength of the administrative record can significantly affect how the case proceeds.
In many situations, the evidence submitted during the appeal is the same evidence a federal court later reviews if the dispute moves to litigation.
Ask for Help With Your Long-Term Disability Coverage Claim
A long-term disability claim denial is more than an insurance dispute. It can affect your ability to support yourself, your family, and your future. J. Price McNamara understands the financial and personal pressure that comes with losing disability benefits and provides focused guidance for clients facing these decisions.
We do not operate as a volume disability practice that treats every claim the same. We focus exclusively on disability, life, and AD&D insurance disputes so your claim can receive careful attention.
Call us at 225-201-8311 to discuss your long-term disability claim with a New Orleans long-term disability lawyer.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Medical Conditions Commonly Qualify for LTD Benefits?
Benefits may be available for any condition that keeps you from performing your job duties, depending on how your policy defines disability. Qualifying conditions can include physical injuries, chronic illnesses, neurological disorders, and mental health conditions. Insurers usually look at how the condition affects your functional abilities, your job duties, and your policy’s requirements.
How Long Do I Have to Appeal a Denied LTD Claim in Louisiana?
Under ERISA regulations governing employer-sponsored LTD plans, claimants generally have a 180-day window to file an appeal. Your exact deadline is listed in your denial letter and plan documents. Missing an appeal deadline can affect your ability to challenge the denial, so review the denial notice and claim documents promptly.
Can I Submit New Medical Evidence After My Appeal Is Denied?
Often it is difficult. In many ERISA LTD cases, courts review only the administrative record created during the claim, so evidence added after the appeal is denied may not count. The appeal stage is usually your key chance to submit medical records and physician opinions, which is why building a complete record before the deadline matters.
Call or text (225) 201-8311 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form
