Life insurance exclusions are specific conditions or circumstances under which the insurance company will not pay a death benefit.
These exclusions protect insurers from certain types of risk, but they are also commonly misapplied to deny valid claims. Knowing which exclusions appear in most policies helps you understand your coverage.
When insurance companies wrongly apply exclusions to deny legitimate claims, our life insurance lawyer can review your case and fight for the benefits your family deserves.
The Suicide Exclusion and Contestability Period
The suicide exclusion appears in nearly every life insurance policy, whether individual or group coverage through an employer.
This exclusion prevents payment of the death benefit if the insured person dies by suicide within a specific timeframe after the policy takes effect.
How the Two-Year Suicide Exclusion Works
Most life insurance policies exclude coverage for suicide during the first two years of coverage. This period is called the contestability period. If the insured person dies by suicide within these first two years, the insurance company typically refunds the premiums paid but does not pay the full death benefit.
The two-year period begins when the policy first takes effect, not when premiums start being paid. For employer-provided group life insurance, the period usually runs from the date you first became eligible for coverage or the date coverage began, depending on policy language.
Disputes Over Cause of Death
Insurance companies sometimes challenge whether a death was actually a suicide, especially in cases involving accidental overdose, single-vehicle accidents, or fatalities where intent is unclear.
The burden of proof typically falls on the insurance company to show the death was suicide, not on the beneficiary to prove it was not.
If an insurance company denies a claim based on the suicide exclusion but the evidence does not clearly support that determination, the denial may be improper. Medical examiner reports, police investigations, and witness statements all play a role in determining the actual cause of death.
For a free legal consultation, call (225) 201-8311
Illegal Activity and Criminal Conduct Exclusions
Many life insurance policies exclude coverage when death occurs during the commission of a crime or while engaged in illegal activity. These exclusions vary significantly in their language and scope.
What Qualifies as Illegal Activity
The illegal activity exclusion typically applies when the insured person dies while committing a felony or engaging in criminal conduct.
Examples might include death during a robbery, fleeing from police, or participating in other serious criminal acts. The key factor is usually whether the illegal activity directly contributed to or caused the death.
Challenges in Applying Criminal Conduct Exclusions
Insurance companies must prove that illegal activity actually occurred and that it caused or contributed to the death. Being present where illegal activity happened does not automatically trigger the exclusion. The insured person must have been actively participating in the unlawful conduct.
These exclusions are frequently disputed because:
- The insured may not have been convicted of any crime (perhaps because they died)
- Evidence of illegal activity may be unclear or circumstantial
- The connection between any unlawful conduct and the death may be indirect
- The policy language may require specific types of crimes that do not apply
Drug and Alcohol Related Deaths
Deaths involving drugs or alcohol create complicated questions about whether the illegal activity exclusion applies. An accidental overdose from prescription medication used improperly differs from an overdose of unlawful drugs.
Deaths in alcohol-related car accidents raise questions about whether the accident itself or the intoxication caused death.
Insurance companies often try to deny claims involving any drug or alcohol presence, even when the policy exclusion requires specific illegal conduct. Many of these denials can be successfully challenged by examining the actual policy language and the circumstances of death.
Hazardous Activities and Aviation Exclusions
Some life insurance policies exclude or limit coverage for deaths occurring during hazardous activities or certain types of aviation.
Aviation Exclusions in Life Insurance Policies
Aviation exclusions typically do not apply to deaths as a passenger on commercial airlines. Instead, they usually exclude coverage for:
- Private aircraft: Operating or riding in private planes
- Small aircraft: Flying in planes below a certain weight or passenger capacity
- Military aviation: Death during military flight operations
- Experimental aircraft: Flying in planes not certified for passenger use
The specific language varies significantly between policies. Some policies exclude all non-commercial aviation, while others only exclude coverage when the insured is operating the aircraft. Reading the exact policy language determines what is actually excluded.
Dangerous Sports and Activities
Certain policies exclude coverage for deaths during hazardous recreational activities. These might include:
- Skydiving and parachuting
- Scuba diving beyond certain depths
- Mountain climbing and rock climbing
- Racing (auto, motorcycle, or boat)
- Hang gliding or base jumping
However, many modern policies have eliminated or limited these exclusions. Employer-provided group life insurance through ERISA plans often does not include hazardous activity exclusions at all. When an exclusion does exist, insurance companies must prove the death occurred during the specific excluded activity.
War and Terrorism Exclusions
Some policies contain war exclusions that prevent payment if death occurs during military service in a war zone or during acts of terrorism. These exclusions are more common in individual policies than in group coverage.
The scope of these exclusions varies widely, and they are frequently challenged when insurers try to apply them to deaths that do not clearly fall within the exclusion language.
Click to contact our insurance claim lawyers today
Pre-Existing Condition Exclusions and Material Misrepresentation
Life insurance policies sometimes exclude coverage based on pre-existing health conditions or alleged misrepresentations on the insurance application.
When Pre-Existing Conditions Can Affect Coverage
During the contestability period (usually the first two years), insurance companies can investigate whether you disclosed all relevant health information on your application.
If the insurance company discovers an undisclosed medical condition during the contestability period, it may deny the claim by alleging material misrepresentation.
To do this, they must prove:
- You failed to disclose information or provided false information
- The information was material (would have affected underwriting decisions)
- You knew the information was false, or deliberately concealed it
The Incontestability Clause Protection
After the two-year contestability period expires, the incontestability clause prevents insurance companies from denying claims based on application errors or undisclosed conditions.
This powerful protection means that once two years have passed, the insurance company generally must pay claims regardless of what was or was not disclosed on the application.
Insurance companies sometimes try to avoid incontestability protections by claiming fraud, but fraud requires proof of intentional deception. Simple mistakes, forgotten information, or conditions you did not know about do not constitute fraud.
Group Life Insurance and Medical Underwriting
Employer-provided group life insurance typically does not require medical underwriting for basic coverage amounts.
This means there is no application where you could have made misrepresentations. Insurance companies cannot deny group life insurance claims based on pre-existing conditions or alleged misrepresentations when no health questions were asked.
Some group plans offer supplemental or optional coverage that requires answering health questions. For these coverage amounts, misrepresentation allegations might apply during the contestability period. However, the basic employer-provided coverage amount remains protected.
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now
Policy Lapse and Non-Payment Life Insurance Exclusions
Life insurance coverage depends on paying premiums as required. When premiums are not paid, coverage can lapse, leading to denied claims.
Understanding Grace Periods
Most life insurance policies provide a grace period after a missed premium payment. This grace period is typically 30 or 31 days. If death occurs during the grace period, the insurance company must still pay the claim, though they will deduct the unpaid premium from the death benefit.
After the grace period expires without payment, coverage terminates. Any death occurring after termination will not be covered unless the policy is reinstated before death occurs.
Employer-Provided Coverage and Premium Payment
For group life insurance through your employer, premiums are typically deducted from your paycheck automatically. Coverage can lapse if you stop receiving paychecks due to leave of absence, disability, or reduced hours, and premium payments stop.
Many employer plans include provisions that continue coverage during certain types of leave or provide a waiver of premium during disability. Understanding your specific plan provisions helps you know whether your coverage continues even when premium deductions cannot be made.
Reinstatement Rights
Some policies allow reinstatement of lapsed coverage if certain conditions are met. This might require payment of past-due premiums, submission of a new application, or evidence of continued insurability.
If you die during a period when you are eligible for reinstatement but have not yet completed the process, disputes can arise about whether coverage should be paid.
Disputes Over Whether Premiums Were Paid
Sometimes insurance companies claim premiums were not paid when the insured person or employer believes they were.
These disputes might involve:
- Premium payments that were sent but not properly credited
- Confusion over due dates or billing amounts
- Electronic payment failures or bank errors
- Employer errors in payroll deductions
Documentation of payment attempts and history can resolve these disputes in the beneficiary’s favor.
Exclusions for Specific Causes of Death
Beyond the major exclusion categories, some policies contain exclusions for particular causes of death that the insurance company wants to avoid covering.
Self-Inflicted Injury Beyond Suicide
Some policies distinguish between suicide and other self-inflicted injuries. For example, accidental self-inflicted injuries typically remain covered even if suicide is excluded. The question becomes whether the self-inflicted injury was intentional (suicide) or accidental.
Insurance companies sometimes claim that risky behavior constitutes self-inflicted injury even when there was no intent to die. These arguments frequently fail because the exclusion requires intentional self-harm, not merely dangerous choices.
Pandemics and Disease Outbreaks
During disease outbreaks, some insurance companies have attempted to deny claims based on war or catastrophe exclusions.
These efforts rarely succeed because standard life insurance exclusions do not typically cover disease or illness, even during pandemics. Life insurance covers natural causes of death, including illness.
Beneficiary Involvement in Death
If a beneficiary murders the insured person, that beneficiary cannot receive the life insurance proceeds. This principle prevents people from profiting from their own crimes.
However, this does not eliminate coverage entirely—the death benefit typically goes to contingent beneficiaries or is paid according to the policy’s order of precedence, skipping the beneficiary who caused the death.
What to Do When Your Claim Is Denied Based on a Life Insurance Exclusion
If an insurance company denies your life insurance claim, citing a policy exclusion, you have the right to challenge that decision.
Review the Denial Letter Carefully
The insurance company must provide a written explanation of why the claim was denied, including the specific policy exclusion they believe applies.
Review this explanation against your actual policy language. Verify that the exclusion actually exists and that it is written the way the insurance company describes it.
Examine the Evidence Behind the Exclusion
Request copies of all documents the insurance company relied on to apply the exclusion. This might include death certificates, medical examiner reports, police reports, autopsy results, or investigation records. Review this evidence to determine whether it actually supports the insurance company’s conclusion.
Understand Your Appeal Rights
For employer-provided life insurance under ERISA, you have 60 days to file an administrative appeal after receiving a denial.
This appeal is mandatory before you can file a lawsuit. The appeal must address the reasons for denial and provide any additional evidence that supports coverage.
For individual life insurance policies, state law governs the appeals process. You may have the right to demand reconsideration, file a complaint with your state insurance department, or proceed directly to litigation, depending on your state’s laws.
Gather Additional Evidence
If the insurance company’s evidence is incomplete or incorrect, gather additional documentation that tells the full story.
This might include:
- Additional medical records showing a different cause of death
- Witness statements contradicting the insurance company’s version of events
- Expert opinions on the cause of death
- Documentation showing the exclusion does not apply to your situation
Consider Legal Representation if You Face a Life Insurance Exclusion Denial
Life insurance exclusion-based denials often involve interpretation of policy language, analysis of medical and investigative evidence, and complex legal arguments.
Our attorneys can evaluate whether the exclusion was properly applied and build the strongest possible appeal or lawsuit to recover the death benefit.
Call or text (225) 201-8311 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form
