Yes, you can and often must transition from Short Term Disability to Long Term Disability (LTD) to continue receiving benefits when your condition lasts beyond the temporary period.
The transition from STD to LTD is not automatic, even if you were approved for the first benefit; you are essentially moving from one type of policy to a different, more complex one.
At ERISA Insurance Claims Attorneys, our long term disability lawyer can help you understand going from short-term disability to long-term disability.
Understanding the Policy Shift
The single most important factor in going from short-term disability to long-term disability is the difference in duration and definition between the two policies. STD is designed for temporary conditions, while LTD is for illnesses or injuries that will prevent you from working for a year or more.
STD policies typically last for a short period, generally between three and twelve months, and have a brief waiting period (or elimination period) before benefits begin. The main goal of STD is to bridge the gap between when you stop working and when a longer-term policy can begin.
LTD policies, conversely, have a much longer elimination period, often 90 to 180 days, which is usually covered by your STD payments. Once the LTD elimination period is met, the benefits can last for years, sometimes until you reach your Social Security retirement age, depending on the specific policy rules.
For a free legal consultation, call (225) 201-8311
The Crucial Change in Disability Definitions
While you are on short-term disability, the insurance company generally uses the “own occupation” definition of disability. This means you qualify for benefits if you are medically unable to perform the main duties of your specific job as you performed it before you became disabled. This is the easier definition to meet.
Long-term disability is very different, as the definition of disability often changes over time. Your LTD policy will likely start with an “own occupation” definition for the first 24 months of payment. However, after that 24-month mark, the definition almost always switches to the stricter “any occupation” standard.
The “any occupation” definition means the insurance company must determine if you can perform any gainful work for which you are reasonably qualified by your education, training, or experience.
This is a much higher hurdle to clear, and this change in definition is the number one reason long-term claims are denied two years into a claim.
The Strategic Timing of the LTD Application
Since long-term disability policies have a long elimination period, you should start the LTD application process while you are still receiving STD benefits. Delaying the application until your short-term disability runs out is a mistake that can lead to a gap in your income.
The LTD elimination period typically runs at the same time as your STD benefit period. Therefore, if you wait until the end of your STD period to apply for LTD, the insurance company may spend several weeks or months reviewing your application, leaving you without any income protection during that time.
We advise clients to begin gathering the necessary documentation and working with their treating physician three to four months before the STD policy is scheduled to terminate. This proactive approach helps ensure there is no unnecessary financial gap when the long-term benefits are scheduled to begin.
Click to contact our insurance claim lawyers today
Why STD Approval Does Not Guarantee LTD Approval
Many people assume that because the same insurance company approved their short-term claim, their long-term claim will be approved automatically. This is a dangerous and often incorrect assumption that leads to heartbreaking claim denials.
The short-term and long-term claims are often handled by different departments within the insurance company, and they are evaluated under different standards. The LTD claims adjuster is specifically trained to look for reasons to deny longer-term benefits because the financial risk to the insurer is much higher.
Furthermore, the medical evidence required for LTD is significantly more detailed. For LTD, the insurer requires updated medical records that clearly explain not just your diagnosis, but your continued functional limitations and why they prevent you from working in the long term.
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now
Importance of Medical Evidence When Going From Short Term Disability to Long Term Disability
The key to a successful transition is providing consistent and comprehensive medical evidence that meets the stricter “any occupation” standard that is often coming down the line. The insurer will scrutinize the medical records to ensure consistency with your initial STD application.
Your treating physician’s statements must clearly link your diagnosis to specific physical or mental work limitations. It is not enough to simply state you are disabled; the doctor must detail why you cannot sit, stand, lift, concentrate, or meet other demands of your prior job, and any job.
We advise that your medical records include objective tests, such as imaging scans, laboratory results, or specialized medical evaluations, to support your subjective complaints of pain or fatigue. The less objective evidence you provide, the easier it is for the claims administrator to deny the LTD claim.
The Role of ERISA in Long-Term Disability Denial
Most employer-provided long-term disability plans fall under the federal law known as ERISA. If your LTD claim is denied, you must follow the strict ERISA claims process before you can take the insurance company to federal court.
This process involves filing a mandatory administrative appeal, where you submit all your supplemental evidence to the insurer for reconsideration. This is your single best chance to build the administrative record that a future judge will review.
At ERISA Insurance Claim Attorneys, we handle appeals nationwide for clients. Since ERISA laws prohibit introducing new evidence once the lawsuit starts, our 30 years of experience in creating a powerful administrative record is important for maximizing your chances of ultimately winning the benefits you deserve.
Learn More About Going From Short-Term Disability to Long-Term Disability
Going from short-term to long-term disability is a high-stakes process in which insurance companies look for reasons to deny long-term benefits. Never assume approval is guaranteed, and never wait until your STD benefits run out to begin the LTD application process.
At ERISA Insurance Claim Attorneys, we offer a free consultation to review your LTD policy and denial letter. We will determine the best strategy for your administrative appeal under ERISA and fight to secure your benefits. Contact us for a free consultation.
Call or text (225) 201-8311 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form
