The Long Path to Justice Under Erisa Law

Our client’s claim illustrates the typical procedural path for claims for insurance benefits governed by ERISA law after the insurance company initially denies a claim.

CIGNA DENIES THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEAL, CONTINUING TO WITHHOLD THE CRITICAL TOXICOLOGY EVIDENCE

CIGNA persisted in its denial of benefits throughout the “administrative appeal” process required by ERISA law. The administrative appeal is where the insurance company basically takes a second look at its own initial claim denial. Throughout the process, CIGNA still never disclosed its toxicologist’s report despite written request on my client’s behalf for any such document. ERISA requires an insurance company who denies a claim to produce all evidence from its investigation to a claimant who requests it. But the insurance companies will sometimes withhold documents they are required to produce if the documents don’t support the denial of benefits.

THE FEDERAL DISTRICT COURT LAWSUIT FOR DENIAL OF ERISA INSURANCE BENEFITS-THE EVIDENCE CIGNA WITHHELD FINALLY COMES TO LIGHT

ERISA law doesn’t allow a claimant to file a lawsuit until after taking an administrative appeal with the insurance company, which usually just results in another denial of benefits. So after CIGNA denied the administrative appeal, we filed suit in federal district court for wrongful denial of ERISA accidental death insurance benefits. CIGNA chose to hire and pay several attorneys from a large corporate law firm to fight against paying the widow’s claim. For the first time, CIGNA, through its attorneys, produced a stack of more than 1000 pages of documents from its investigation, never produced before. Its toxicology expert’s critical report, just a few pages long, was buried deep within it.

We presented this newly-revealed report to the unbiased Coroner, the physician who actually signed my client’s husband’s death certificate, and asked him for his opinion. The Coroner gave us a sworn statement, testifying in agreement with CIGNA’s own toxicologist, that the blood and urine samples could not support a finding of intoxication or impairment.

At that point, we hoped and really thought that reason would prevail once we shared this with CIGNA. We pointed out to CIGNA what its own expert and the Coroner said about impairment and intoxication, but even this didn’t change CIGNA’s mind. Remember, paying claims, whether legitimate or not, doesn’t help insurance company profits. CIGNA’s thought must have been that paying its attorneys to fight the court battle, if they could win, would be less expensive than paying benefits to a deserving claimant.

Believe it or not, citing ERISA legal technicalities, CIGNA’s lawyers told us that CIGNA wouldn’t even consider the unbiased Coroner’s affidavit because it had already completed its investigation. CIGNA’s attorneys then actually argued against letting the judge even consider the affidavit as evidence at trial. The attorneys cited to the ERISA technicality that the court can’t consider evidence that was not presented to the insurance company to consider during the administrative appeal process.

So we took the case to trial, but to my client’s dismay, the district court judge ruled in favor of CIGNA and against my client citing technicalities of ERISA law. A third gut punch.

Our Client Testimonials

This has been a very difficult time for myself and my family. Mr. Mcnamara did his best to be as empathetic and compassionate as possible. He is very knowledgeable and a man of great integrity.

Nicole

This has been a very difficult time for me and my family, but Mr.Mcnamara has been very empathetic and understanding. He is extremely knowledgeable and a man of great integrity. I truly appreciate everything he did to make this as Tolerable as possible.

Nicole

I am so thankful Price was my attorney during this difficult time in my life after losing my fiance. He made me feel very comfortable I trusted that he had my best interests in mind. I highly recommend him I was truly blessed to have had him help me fight for what is mine.

Priscilla

I would like to take a moment to thank Mr. Price McNamara for the leadership of legal counsel aid him and his staff showed through the entire process of working with me with my Disability case. I will highly recommend Mr. Price McNamara to anyone that needs someone that is outstanding to fight for their

James

Price was instrumental in assisting me through the disability process. Without his help and guidance , I do not think that I would have been successful !!!! Thank you Price.

Gregory Smith

Mr Price is great attorney with great skills and lot of experience. But BEST QUALITY he has that he is wonderful human being he care for your family and you as a human being. My family thanks you very much. GOD bless you and your staff.

Gerald

The law firm of Price McNamara has successfully settled our law suit when other attorneys said that we had no case Price assured us that we did and in eight months he was able to negotiate a settlement that we were told that we could not get. I highly recommend his law firm and I

Jim Couder

I want to say thanks to J. Price McNamara for the sound free advice he gave me related how to increase my chances of being approved for Long Term Disability of being denied. I must say after implementing elements of his sound advice such as showing the insurance company proof of how my illness/disability had

Gwendolyn Miller

I needed an attorney with a specific specialty and Price McNamara was definitely the right choice. His representation was based on principles that are probably unsurpassed by any other attorney in the field. McNamara represents individuals, not big-money corporations, like so many others in his field of specialty. He is a consummate professional, extremely knowledgeable

Hurst

I found Mr. McNamara to be practical and efficient. He did what I needed in a reasonable amount of time, keeping me well informed and with excellent results. He communicated with me clearly and on a timely basis. I will use him in the future.

JMP

I am a current client of Mr. McNamara’s. He is very accessible and responds to my emails and phone calls in a timely manner. I find him to be very professional and knowledgeable, as well as ready, willing and able to address all of my questions and/or concerns.

Elizabeth

I am an attorney. Price represented me, and in a separate suit represented my daughter, for injuries. He moved the cases at lightning speed and obtained maximum recovery. I was grateful and surprised. I would recommend Price to anyone who wants a top-notch attorney who gets results.

Anonymous Client

I would recommend Mr. Mcnanmara to anyone at any time. He was the best attorney that my family and I came in contact with. About three years ago we had a very tragic, accidental death in our family and the company knew that it was their fault but of course tried passing the buck. Mr.

Client Impacted by a Wrongful Death

Price and Sara are great. They helped us in a time of need. Their communication was always spot on and I never felt out of the loop with what was going on with our case.

Michael

Price is very professional, honest, and reliable. Whatever he says, he will follow through with the utmost integrity. He will turn over every stone and pays close attention to even the smallest detail. I’m glad I secured his services.

A Happy Client

Without going into the painful details regarding the reason for having to hire Price, his compassion and communication helped my family during an extremely difficult time. If you need legal help because you or a family member was injured by something or someone else, don’t hesitate to call him.

Mike