When an insurer drags out a claim, ignores your evidence, or refuses to pay benefits it owes, it can feel like the company is betting you will give up. A Baton Rouge insurance bad faith lawyer at J. Price McNamara: Disability, Life, AD&D Insurance Attorneys can tell you which remedies actually apply to your claim, depending on what kind of coverage you have.
Attorney Price McNamara spent the early part of his career, starting in 1990, defending insurance companies. He knows how claim files are built to justify a denial, and he now uses that experience for disability, life, and AD&D claimants in Baton Rouge and nationwide.
Call 225-201-8311 for a free denial review. We advance all costs and are paid only if we recover benefits for you.
Why Baton Rouge Claimants Choose J. Price McNamara: Disability, Life, AD&D Insurance Attorneys
Baton Rouge claimants choose us because we concentrate on insurance-benefit claims and understand both sides of a bad-faith dispute.
What we bring to your case:
- Defense-Side Experience: Price McNamara is a former insurance company defense attorney.
- Focused Practice: 30+ years focused on disability, life, and AD&D insurance-benefit claims.
- Recognition: AV Preeminent peer review rating, Martindale-Hubbell; 10/10 rating, Avvo; A+ rating, Better Business Bureau; and The National Trial Lawyers Top 100.
- A Baton Rouge Home Office: Meetings at 9431 Common St. by appointment, with most work handled virtually.
New clients have a 30-day opportunity to determine whether we’re the right fit. Put a former insurance company insider on your side. Contact J. Price McNamara for a free denial review.
For a free legal consultation, call (225) 201-8311
Does Louisiana Bad Faith Law Apply to Your Claim?
Louisiana’s insurance penalty statutes apply to policies governed by state law, but they generally do not apply to employer-sponsored plans governed by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). That single distinction decides which remedies are available, so it is the first thing we determine.
| Employer plan governed by ERISA | Policy governed by Louisiana law | |
| Typical coverage | Group disability, life, or AD&D through work | Individual policies and some non-ERISA plans |
| State bad faith penalties | Generally preempted by federal law | May apply under the Louisiana Insurance Code |
| Main remedy | Benefits due under the plan, plus possible attorney’s fees | Benefits plus statutory penalties, interest, or fees, depending on the statute |
| Where the case is heard | State or federal court after an internal appeal | State or federal court |
| Key evidence rule | Usually limited to the record built during the appeal | New evidence can generally be presented at trial |
Government plans and many church plans are not governed by ERISA, so coverage through a public employer may open the door to state-law remedies. We check the plan documents before advising you either way.
Why ERISA Displaces State Bad Faith Claims
In Pilot Life v. Dedeaux, the U.S. Supreme Court held that ERISA preempts state-law bad faith claims arising from the processing of benefits under an ERISA plan. For most employer-sponsored coverage, that means the claim proceeds under federal law rather than Louisiana’s penalty statutes.
What ERISA Offers Instead
ERISA’s civil enforcement section lets a participant or beneficiary sue to recover benefits due under the plan and allows the court to award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs. The remedy is narrower than a state bad-faith claim, which makes it even more important to build a complete record during the internal appeal.
Louisiana Bad Faith Insurance Penalties for Disability, Life, and AD&D Claims
For policies governed by Louisiana law, the Insurance Code sets specific payment deadlines and penalties for each type of coverage. The statute that applies depends on whether the claim involves disability, life, or accidental death benefits.
Disability and Other Health and Accident Claims
Louisiana R.S. 22:1821 requires claims under health and accident contracts to be paid within 30 days after written notice and proof of claim, unless just and reasonable grounds exist. An insurer that fails to comply can owe a penalty of double the benefits due during the period of delay, together with attorney’s fees set by the court.
The same statute requires accidental death claims under health and accident contracts to be settled within 60 days after due proof of death. If the insurer fails to do so without just cause, the amount due bears 6% annual interest from the date it received proof.
Life Insurance Death Claims
Louisiana R.S. 22:1811 requires life insurers to settle death claims within 60 days after receiving due proof of death. If the insurer fails to do so without just cause, the amount due bears interest at 8% per year from the date of proof.
Why the General Penalty Statute Usually Does Not Apply
Louisiana’s general claims penalty statute, R.S. 22:1892, covers policies other than life and health and accident insurance. Disability, life, and AD&D claims are therefore measured against the more specific statutes above, which is an easy point to overlook.
Click to contact our insurance claim lawyers today
What Counts as a Wrongful Denial of Benefits?
A denial may be wrongful when the insurer ignores the policy language, overlooks or mischaracterizes evidence, or fails to follow the claim procedures the law requires. Not every denial is bad faith, but many denials are not supported by the record once the full claim file is reviewed.
Examples include:
- Relying on a records-only review while disregarding detailed opinions from your treating physicians
- Applying an exclusion the policy language does not clearly support
- Describing your job as lighter or less demanding than it really is
- Requesting the same information repeatedly while the payment deadline passes
- Changing the reason for denial late in the process without giving you a chance to respond
- Failing to explain why your evidence was rejected
For ERISA disability claims, the insurer must explain why it disagreed with your treating providers and share any new rationale before a final denial. When an insurer fails to follow those rules, the claim may be treated as exhausted, which can allow a lawsuit to proceed.
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now
What Should You Do if You Suspect a Bad Faith Denial of Benefits?
If you suspect a bad-faith denial of benefits, identify your deadlines and preserve a written record before responding to the insurer. Those steps matter whether the claim ends up under ERISA or Louisiana law.
Put Every Request in Writing
Phone calls with an adjuster leave little trace, while letters and emails create a clear timeline. A dated record of what you sent and when the insurer responded is often the strongest evidence of unreasonable delay.
Track the Insurer’s Deadlines
Note the date you submitted proof of claim and the date of each request for more information. Under Louisiana law, those dates can determine whether penalties apply, and under ERISA, they show whether the plan met the federal decision deadlines.
Ask for the Claim File Early
The claim file shows what the insurer reviewed, who reviewed it, and what was said internally about your claim. Seeing it before you respond to a denial lets you answer the insurer’s actual reasoning rather than guessing at it.
Get Legal Help Before You File Your Appeal
Our Baton Rouge insurance bad faith lawyers can review the denial, identify your appeal deadline, and determine what evidence needs to be added before you respond. For an ERISA claim, that work is especially important because the evidence submitted during the appeal can shape what a court reviews later.
How Our Baton Rouge Insurance Bad Faith Lawyers Can Help
Our Baton Rouge insurance bad faith lawyers can review the denial, examine the claim file, identify which laws and deadlines apply, and build the evidence needed to challenge the insurer’s decision.
Attorney Price McNamara previously represented insurance companies, and he draws on that experience to recognize how insurers build denial files and where weaknesses may appear.
Review the Insurer’s Claim File
A claim file can show how long the insurer took to act, which doctors or consultants it relied on, what evidence it considered, and what it may have overlooked. Reviewing that file helps us identify weaknesses in the denial and determine what evidence needs to be addressed.
Identify the Right Legal Remedy
The available remedy depends heavily on the type of coverage. An ERISA claim may require an internal appeal and later federal litigation, while a policy governed by Louisiana law may allow statutory penalties or interest if the insurer failed to meet its obligations.
Build a Stronger Response to the Denial
A short letter saying the insurer was wrong is rarely enough. We gather medical, vocational, or other evidence that responds directly to the reasons given for the denial and make sure that the evidence becomes part of the record before important deadlines pass.
Hold the Insurer to the Policy and the Law
Our Baton Rouge insurance bad faith lawyers compare the insurer’s conduct with the policy language and the rules that govern the claim. If the insurer ignored evidence, applied an exclusion incorrectly, missed a required deadline, or failed to follow proper claim procedures, we address those issues as part of the appeal or lawsuit.
How We Handle Baton Rouge Bad Faith and Benefits Cases
Every case starts by identifying whether federal or state law governs the coverage because that affects the deadlines, the remedies, and the court. From there, our Baton Rouge insurance bad faith lawyers follow our custom 5-step plan:
- Gather: The policy, plan documents, and the insurer’s complete claim file.
- Organize: The timeline of the claim, including every request and response.
- Analyze: Whether the insurer met its deadlines and applied the policy correctly.
- Build: New medical, vocational, or factual evidence that answers the denial.
- Execute: The appeal or lawsuit, including any statutory penalty claim that applies.
For ERISA plans, lawsuits from Baton Rouge are typically filed in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Louisiana. Claims under Louisiana-law policies may proceed in state court, such as the 19th Judicial District Court for East Baton Rouge Parish, or in federal court.
FAQs: Insurance Bad Faith Lawyer Baton Rouge
Can I sue my disability insurer for bad faith in Louisiana?
You may be able to seek Louisiana statutory penalties if your disability policy is governed by state law, such as an individual policy. If the disability coverage is an employer plan governed by ERISA, state bad faith claims are generally preempted, and the remedy is usually a federal claim for benefits and possible attorney’s fees.
How do I know if my plan is governed by ERISA?
Most disability, life, and AD&D coverage provided through a private employer is governed by ERISA. The summary plan description often says so, and coverage through a government employer or a church may fall outside ERISA, so the plan documents should be checked.
How long does an insurer have to pay a claim in Louisiana?
Under Louisiana law, health and accident claims, including disability, generally must be paid within 30 days after proof of claim, while life insurance and accidental death claims generally must be settled within 60 days after due proof of death. These deadlines apply to policies governed by Louisiana law, not to most ERISA plans.
Should I file a complaint with the Louisiana Department of Insurance?
Filing a complaint with the Louisiana Department of Insurance is an option for policies regulated by the state, but it doesn’t replace an appeal or lawsuit. If your claim has an appeal deadline, that deadline keeps running while a complaint is reviewed.
What does a Baton Rouge insurance bad faith lawyer cost?
Our Baton Rouge insurance bad faith lawyers work on a contingency fee, so you pay nothing up front and owe zero fee if we don’t recover benefits for you. Our firm fronts all out-of-pocket costs, including expert fees and medical records.
The contingency fee has a hard dollar cap and doesn’t increase if the case goes to litigation. Any attorney fee awarded by the court on a win goes to the client, not the firm.
When a Denial Doesn’t Add Up
If an insurer’s explanation does not match your records or your policy, you should get a clear answer about what the law allows. J. Price McNamara: Disability, Life, AD&D Insurance Attorneys can review your claim, identify whether federal or Louisiana law controls, and explain what it would take to challenge the decision.
A free review covers the governing law, your deadlines, and whether any penalty statute applies, so you can decide your next step with the full picture.
Put a former insurance company insider on your side. Contact J. Price McNamara for a free denial review, or look into our past results.
Call or text (225) 201-8311 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form
