Disability benefits may be taxable depending on who paid the insurance premiums and how the plan was structured.
In general, if you paid the premiums with after-tax dollars, your long-term disability (LTD) benefits are not taxable. However, if your employer paid for the policy or you used pre-tax income to cover the cost, some or all of the benefits may be taxed as income.
Because tax rules differ based on your situation, it’s often helpful to speak with a professional who understands both Social Security and private LTD policies.
A Baton Rouge long-term disability lawyer may be able to explain how the rules apply in your case and what steps to take if your benefits are taxed incorrectly.
When Are Disability Benefits Not Taxable?
Disability benefits are not taxed when:
- You purchased the plan yourself using after-tax dollars.
- Your share of premiums came from after–tax income, and your employer did not contribute.
- The policy is individual and not part of an employer group plan.
In these cases, the IRS considers the benefit a return on your own investment. Since you already paid taxes on the money used to buy the policy, you are not taxed again when receiving benefits.
This is most common with private long-term disability policies or supplemental plans purchased outside of your employer.
For a free legal consultation, call (225) 201-8311
When Are Disability Benefits Taxable?
Disability benefits are taxable when:
- Your employer paid the full premium.
- You paid premiums through a pre-tax payroll deduction.
- The policy is part of a group plan funded by your workplace.
In these situations, benefits are treated as taxable income and must be reported on your tax return. Your insurer or employer will typically send a Form W-2 or 1099 outlining the amount you must include when filing.
What If the Premiums Were Split?
In many workplaces, the cost of disability insurance is shared between the employer and the employee. If that’s your situation, only part of the benefit may be taxable.
Here’s how it generally breaks down:
- Employer–paid portion: Taxable
- Employee–paid portion with after–tax dollars: Non-taxable
- Employee–paid portion with pre–tax dollars: Taxable
In cases where premiums were split or where part of your contribution was tax deducted, you may owe taxes on a portion of your monthly LTD payments. The IRS may require you to calculate the taxable percentage based on the funding breakdown.
Click to contact our insurance claim lawyers today
How Social Security Disability Benefits Are Taxed
Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) benefits are taxed differently than private LTD benefits. Whether your SSDI is taxable depends on your total income, including any LTD benefits you may be receiving.
You may owe federal taxes on SSDI if:
- You file individually and your total income exceeds $25,000 per year.
- You file jointly and your household income exceeds $32,000 per year.
If your income is below these thresholds, your SSDI benefits are not taxable. These income limits include your spouse’s income and any other taxable benefits you receive. Keep in mind that Supplemental Security Income (SSI), a separate needs-based benefit, is never taxable.
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now
How Taxation Impacts Lump Sum Settlements
If your LTD claim is resolved with a lump sum settlement, tax issues become more complicated. The IRS may treat the entire amount as income for the year it is received. Depending on the size of the settlement, this could push you into a higher tax bracket and result in a larger tax bill.
Taxation of lump sum disability settlements depends on:
- Who paid the original premiums
- How long the benefit period covers
- Whether the settlement includes future estimated payments
In some cases, it may be possible to negotiate the tax treatment of a settlement or spread the payments out over multiple years. This is an area where professional guidance is especially important.
How a Long-Term Disability Law Firm Can Help
Understanding whether your benefits are taxable can help you plan ahead and avoid surprises during tax season. But when benefits are denied or cut off, tax questions often take a back seat to more urgent concerns.
A long-term disability law firm can help you:
- Review your policy to determine who paid the premiums and whether benefits should be taxed.
- Identify errors in tax documents issued by the insurer or employer.
- Appeal a claim denial or early termination.
- Prepare for federal court litigation under ERISA if needed.
At ERISA Insurance Claim Attorneys, we work with clients across the country to appeal LTD denials and fight unfair benefit reductions. We help ensure that clients receive the full value of their benefits, including after-tax calculations where applicable.
What to Watch for on Your Tax Forms
If your LTD benefits are taxable, you should receive one of the following:
- Form W–2 if benefits are paid through your employer
- Form 1099–MISC or Form 1099–R if paid by an insurance company
Review these forms carefully. If you believe the amount reported is incorrect or does not match your payment history, you may need to request a correction or provide documentation to the IRS.
Even if you believe your benefits are not taxable, it’s a good idea to consult a tax professional, especially if your situation involves both LTD and SSDI benefits or a settlement.
Contact a Long-Term Disability Lawyer
Knowing whether your disability benefits are taxable is only part of the equation. If you are facing a denied claim, reduced benefits, or a confusing settlement offer, legal guidance can help you avoid costly mistakes.
A long-term disability lawyer will review your policy, explain how tax rules apply to your benefits, and help protect your financial future. Whether you’re currently receiving payments or trying to secure benefits after a denial, the right legal support makes a difference.
At ERISA Insurance Claim Attorneys, we have been helping clients with injuries and disabilities for more than 30 years. We will take the time to truly listen and understand your situation before working to get you the benefits you need and deserve.
Call or text (225) 201-8311 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form
